Shrink the debt
The problem
The national debt has continued to rise regardless of who is in government. The Reform approach would be no different: much like Truss, they want to cut taxes without making the corresponding cuts to expenditure. We are all for tax cuts, but they must not be funded by borrowing. To provide tax cuts in this way is Keynesianism at its worst: a short term solution that leaves us bleeding red ink.
And why is the national debt such a problem? You would be forgiven for not knowing given the distinct lack of interest in this issue from our politicians. Well, here’s the problem:
if borrowing outstrips economic growth for a prolonged period, lenders become concerned about the government’s ability to pay them back without the aid of inflation i.e., weakening the currency to reduce the debt in real terms
this concern then leads to lenders offering the government less favourable rates, which means that more of the government’s budget is spent on paying interest
if this pattern continues, the government must rely on some combination of tax increases, spending cuts and inflation to service the debt
so, the short-term largesse that comes with borrowing is followed by a course correction that either leaves the people with less money in their pockets or on the receiving end of a poorly funded state
that is why periods of high borrowing have tended to end in tears, with the resulting course correction hammering the people who were told the borrowed money was all for them
The solution
Balance the budget now. Not next year, not ‘when the time is right’. It is the sense that being deep in debt is the norm that is killing us. It absolutely is not: small amounts of borrowing that can easily be refinanced can be tolerated, but a national debt the size of the economy is the privilege of countries engaged in a world war. Acceptance of this fact is the first step towards a cure.
What then? Contrary to what many conservatives say, tax rises should be on the table when a country is spending beyond its means. The difficulty now is that we have a large national debt and a sluggish economy, so further tax rises should be avoided if at all possible. And if we take that view, the alternative can only be cuts, real cuts that dramatically alter the people’s relationship with the state. This necessarily means putting the major costs on the table: welfare, health, education, and defence cannot be immune.